Tuesday, October 24, 2006

Future of Sri Lankan Elephants: the wild or the sheltered?

I was watching a tv prog today about Sri Lankan Elephants. And what did I learn from it? I really don’t know for it left me asking more questions at the end than I had at the beginning. Especially since I’d just heard that SB Dissanayake had requested Ranil W to appoint him as the Assistant Leader of the UNP. Kinda funny ain’t it? Me ! Me! Did I say Me?

Anyways, to get to the Elephant story:

Elephants in Sri Lanka are respected and held in high-esteem. One man (in the tv prog) even went as far as to say that if there are no elephants, there is no country. However this sentimental view is not wholly shared by villagers who can’t sleep at night for fear of elephant attacks. They don’t see the elephant through the rosy hue that others do. For them, it’s not about the “elephants”. It’s about the one elephant that terrorizes them every night. The Wild Elephant.

The Wild Elephant, the one that is unloved for his uncouth ways. He does not fit in with the elephants that are respected at all those dignified Perahera’s. So what do the people think should be done to him? Killed? No, no, a village woman says. Elephants need not be killed. Just this wild uncouth one must be removed so that they can get on with their lives in peace.

A conservationist later talks of the problems brought about by elephant orphanages – they were meant to be (and still are) institutions which care/d for orphaned elephants. However, the elephants within those gates have doubled and tripled over the years and none of them can now be released into the wild for they were born “in captivity” and could not survive “in the wild.” What a conundrum this is. But then again, nevermind elephants, even men with the best of intentions, born in captivity and shelter, can't really and truly survive in the wild these days can they?

There was more in the prog about people and elephant migration and several what-to-do's that were not all that interesting, hence shall not be repeated here.

But, now I’m left trying to answer questions I had not thought of before.

At the end of the day, which ones are the best?

Those born in shelter who knows not the ways of the world?

OR

Those born in the wild who knows not common decency and self-respect?

Elephant and Baby - Wasgamuwa Park (Dec 2004)

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

...thats right. blame it on the ELEPHANTS! :) but both kinds became a problem only in relation to humans, didnt they?

Anonymous said...

Oh... I never lived in a village that was constantly rampaged by wild jumbos. But even in the middle of Kandy, we used to get an elephant or two from the 'Maligawa' in our front yard almost every month as their caretakers take them around looking for jack-leaves. (And elephants of the two-legged kind looking for 'manapes' during election time). It’s enough to have been chased by 'waliga kota' in the Udawalawe National park to know the wrath of a wild elephant, but wild or tame, they are truly amazing animals.
But the point is, the questions you raise are flawed, the generalisation you make is shallow. The 'maligawa tusker' which carries the tooth-relic is supposed to be 'sheltered' can be as uncouth as ‘waliga kota’ and some wild elephants have been documented to be decent and gentle. Even the anima world is not so black and white and a person’s or animal’s upbringing is not the defining factor in his/her/its character!

Manshark said...

Jokerman: Trust you to come up wit the winner! ;o)

Manshark said...

Oh GOD!! Someone's put this post on Elephant News!! But with the SB/ UNP bit edited out..He he heh..too bloody funny!

Manshark said...

Anon: Did you really and truly take all this so seriously? *sigh* Didn't mean to step on any tails - long or short! ;oD

halwis said...

What would "waliga kota" think of getting pregnant?? no.. its not a lame question... when you talk of a man getting pregnant, culture and perceptions come into play no... but how about we help males in the animal kingdom (including the lion kings) get pregnant?? especially those on the endangered list ha!